WP139 | The Marketing Loop You Can't Afford to Ignore with Joshua Brummel

Ready to turn your “meh” marketing into momentum? In this episode, Joshua joins us to break down the magic of feedback loops—what they are, why they matter, and how you can use them to stop guessing and start growing your practice. Whether you’re rocking a solo gig or scaling a group practice, there’s one thing that makes all the difference: paying attention to what’s working (and what’s not). From website wins to Psychology Today pitfalls to Google Ads that actually perform, Joshua shares friendly, down-to-earth wisdom—with a wink of humor and plenty of “a-ha” moments along the way.

If you’ve ever wondered why your beautiful new website isn’t bringing in new clients, or why your ads feel like shouting into the void, this one’s for you. Tune in and let’s tighten that marketing game, one smart tweak at a time. 💡

What Is a Feedback Loop?

In Joshua’s words, a feedback loop is simple:

Look at what’s happening. Measure it. Take action. Repeat.

Got a Psychology Today profile? Great. Are you getting leads from it? No? Then optimize it. Update your photo. Refine your copy. Test something new. Complete the loop.

Sounds simple, right? But here’s the kicker—most people stop after step one. They launch something, don’t measure it, and then wonder why it’s not working.

The Era of Pretty Websites Is Over (Sort Of)

It’s easier than ever to DIY a gorgeous site using tools like Canva and drag-and-drop builders. But a good-looking website is just the starting point.

If you’re not tracking site traffic, conversions, and lead generation, you’re missing the point.

Joshua puts it plainly: “If you build that great, beautiful website and you don’t measure… we’re missing a critical step.”

Think of it like building a boat that floats beautifully—but doesn’t move. Function matters. Pretty doesn’t pay the bills.

Every Channel Has Its Own Feedback Loop

Joshua breaks down how different marketing channels—Google Ads, SEO, Psychology Today, etc.—each require their own rhythm of evaluation.

Years ago, you could set up a Google Ad and let it run for months. These days?

You might need to check performance daily.

Why? Because competition is fierce, trends change quickly, and platforms shift under your feet. Think of it like steering a boat down a fast-moving river—you’ve got to course correct constantly or get swept away.

Red, Yellow, Green: Joshua’s Simple Traffic Light System

You don’t need to be a data nerd to evaluate your marketing efforts. Joshua offers a super simple way to assess any channel:

  • Green – It’s working well. Keep going or do more of it.

  • Yellow – It’s okay, but could be better. Time to optimize.

  • Red – It’s broken. Stop and rework it entirely.

Even if you have no clue what “normal” is for something like SEO or a Facebook ad, you can ask around, do some research (hello, ChatGPT!), and get some baseline indicators to judge where you stand.

Reality Check: Therapy Marketing Isn’t So “Special” Anymore

Joshua drops a truth bomb here:

The therapy space now performs a lot like other health and wellness markets.

What used to be a more affordable ad landscape is catching up to dental, chiropractic, and other competitive niches. That means you can no longer shrug off average conversion benchmarks and assume therapy is “different.”

For example, a 1–3% conversion rate on Psychology Today? That’s considered pretty normal now. If you're not seeing that, it’s time to revisit your headline, photo, or specialties.

Small Changes = Big Results

Joshua encourages practice owners to stop swinging for the fences and start making small, measurable tweaks.

Change a hero image. Rewrite a call to action. Test different intake forms.

Even a 1% improvement in a conversion rate can double your leads if it moves you from 1% to 2%. That’s not a typo. That’s math magic.

So instead of overhauling everything, look for micro-optimizations—what Joshua calls the “1–2% changes” that add up fast.

Build the Rhythm or Find a Partner

You’ve got two options:

  1. Create your own rhythm. Schedule weekly check-ins with yourself or your team. Review your numbers. Tweak what’s not working.

  2. Hire a partner who actually measures success. And don’t be afraid to ask vendors the tough questions:

  • “How do you measure success?”

  • “What metrics will we review?”

  • “What do your other clients see after launch?”

If a website designer can’t tell you whether their sites convert, you’re just paying for digital eye candy.

Final Thought: Don’t Confuse Activity With Progress

Just because you posted to Instagram, launched a website, or signed up for a listing doesn’t mean you’re moving forward. Joshua’s central message is clear:

“Without the feedback loop of sitting down every week and going top to bottom through all of the layers... you often won’t reach the goals that you want in this market anymore.”

So whether you're a solo clinician building your side hustle or a group practice ready to scale, it's time to stop guessing and start measuring.

After all, marketing is no longer a one-and-done game—it’s a weekly rhythm, a living experiment, and a whole lot more strategic than just making things look nice.

Show Sponsor Simplified SEO Consulting

You help clients every day—now let us help you! At Simplified SEO Consulting, we specialize in SEO and social media marketing designed just for therapists. Our team has mental health degrees and hands-on experience, giving us a unique edge in crafting ethical, engaging content that attracts your ideal clients. This June, we’re launching a Social Media Management Package—and for a limited time, select clients can get 10% off, saving up to $480! With pricing options to fit any budget, we’ll create a strategy that works for you. Claim your discount today!

https://simplifiedseoconsulting.com/apply-to-work-with-us/

Joshua’s Resources

Website

Instagram

Facebook

Links and Resources

The Wise Practice Summit

Wise Practice Membership

Looking for support and connection: Join the Wise Practice Community

Learn More about Wise Practice Consulting

Connect with Wise Practice on Instagram

Connect with Whitney Owens on Facebook

Check the podcasts on the PsychCraft Network

Previous
Previous

WP140 | Run Profitable and Give Generously with Nate Hendrikse

Next
Next

WP138 | Leading Your Practice in an Uncertain Economy with David W. Frank, CFP®