WP144 | Rethink Your Marketing: Fresh Strategies to Be Seen and Heard with Jimmy McKay, PT, DPT

Ever feel like you’re shouting into the void on social media—and still hearing crickets? Wondering why those three reels a week aren’t filling your practice?

This episode of The Wise Practice Podcast is your wake-up call (and your permission slip to do content differently).

I sit down with Jimmy McKay—physical therapist turned podcasting powerhouse—to talk about how practice owners can scale their voice, grow their impact, and finally start showing up online in a way that actually works.

Jimmy breaks down exactly why content isn’t about going viral—it’s about earning trust. He’ll show you how one hour a week can turn into 50 pieces of value-packed content, and why your podcast (or video or blog) should be your most powerful salesperson.

If you’re ready to cut through the noise, connect with the right clients, and stop feeling invisible online, this one’s for you.

Your Podcast Isn’t the Product—Your Audience Is

One of Jimmy’s core messages? If you’re podcasting (or creating any kind of content), you’re not selling the thing. You’re building an audience, and that audience is the product.

"CBS doesn’t sell shows. They sell audiences to advertisers."

That simple reframe is a game-changer for therapists, coaches, and practice owners who want to grow their business without shouting into the void. It’s not about being everywhere. It’s about being in the right places for the right people—and earning their trust.

From Three Reels a Week to 50 Pieces of Content

Think posting three times a week is enough? Think again.

Jimmy breaks down why content needs to be frequent, intentional, and repurposed. One 60-minute podcast can become:

  • Video clips

  • Audiograms

  • Quote graphics

  • Instagram carousels

  • Blog posts

  • Email newsletters

  • ...and more

This isn’t about working harder—it’s about working smarter with a system that scales.

“If I only called my girlfriend three times a week, would I expect the relationship to grow?”

Oof. Message received.

Speak to Your Audience, Not at Them

Most practice owners fall into the trap of saying “I” and “we” too early in their messaging. Jimmy challenges us to flip the script.

Instead of “We offer therapy for overwhelmed moms,” try:

👉 “Feel like you’re doing everything for everyone and still falling short? You’re not alone. Here’s how therapy can help.”

That subtle shift puts your audience at the center of the conversation, not you.

7-11-4: The Trust-Building Formula

You might need 7 hours of content, spread across 11 interactions, on 4 different platforms, before someone buys from you.

Sound overwhelming? Not if you’re strategic. A weekly podcast + clips + email = trust on autopilot.

This framework isn’t about manipulation. It’s about consistency—and making sure the right people find, like, and trust you before they ever book a call.

You’re Not Pizza or Ice Cream

Worried about being “too much” on social media?

Jimmy’s advice: GOOD.

“If too much of me is too much, you’re not my person anyway.”

Your goal isn’t to attract everyone. It’s to attract the right ones—and repel the rest. That’s how you protect your energy, your practice, and your mission.

Jab, Jab, Jab… Right Hook

Give. Give. Give. Then ask.

Jimmy calls out the “Gary Vee” model of content marketing: drop consistent value with no ask, and then go for the sale when it makes sense.

When has someone seen 40+ pieces of content from you that helped them? That $800 workshop isn’t a hard sell—it’s the next logical step.

How Jimmy Helps Practice Owners Show Up (Without Burning Out)

Jimmy now works with healthcare professionals—PTs, OTs, SLPs, MDs, therapists—to create scalable, done-for-you content systems. All he asks is one thing:

“Can you give me one hour a week? If you can do that, I can give you 50 pieces of content that reflect who you are and what you do.”

That’s 1 hour of your time for 50 chances to earn trust, build a connection, and grow your business.

If you’re still stuck thinking content has to be overwhelming, awkward, or a full-time job? This episode will flip that belief on its head—and give you the tools to start showing up in a way that actually feels good.

Show Sponsor My Best Practice

Try My Best Practice, the EHR built by and for evidence-based therapists.

It’s designed to make therapy easier, with features like:

  • AI SOAP & Progress Notes

  • 2-Way Google Calendar Sync

  • A mobile app for phones

  • Telehealth, group appointments and group notes

  • Customizable forms, notes, and treatment plans

  • Built-in payroll reports

And everything else solo practitioners and group practices love.

Enjoy responsive customer support, an easy-to-use interface, and a comprehensive how-to library with step-by-step screenshots.

If you want to save time, reduce your stress, and make evidence-based care easy, My Best Practice is your EHR.

And here’s why: It was named Best Overall EHR in Mental Health for 2025 for the second year in a row and was the first EHR ever awarded 5 out of 5 stars by Choosing Therapy.

Get 3 months free!

Sign up at: https://referral.mbpractice.com/ref/wisepractice

Jimmy McKay’s Resources

jimmy@ptpintcast.com

Website

Instagram

X

Facebook

Links and Resources

The Wise Practice Summit

Wise Practice Membership

Looking for support and connection: Join the Wise Practice Community

Learn More about Wise Practice Consulting

Connect with Wise Practice on Instagram

Connect with Whitney Owens on Facebook

Check the podcasts on the PsychCraft Network

Previous
Previous

WP145 | How EOS Brings Stability and Purpose to Your Business with Tara Vossenkemper, PhD, LPC

Next
Next

WP143 | 5 Pitfalls of Bootstrapped Practice Owners with Neal Samudre